Jakob, der Lügner aka Jacob the LiarJacob lives in a Polish ghetto during World War II, which setting is depicted very believably. He tells a white lie of owning a radio, and from there the lie escalates out of control. Manuela plays a girl who is still too young to understand the grim reality, and is very touching with her childish optimism.
Jakob, der Lügner (Jacob the Liar) is based on a book by a
Polish-born writer who as a child lived for two years at the Łódź
ghetto, where the movie takes place. His mother, like much of the
population of the ghetto, later died in the Holocaust.
The movie focuses on Jacob, who happens to hear from the radio of the
guards that the Russian army is only 20 kilometers from a nearby town. As a
white lie he claims to his friend that he heard that from his own radio.
The rumor spreads quickly, and Jacob gets deeper and deeper into the web of
his own lies. He's too embarrassed to reveal the truth, but also likes
giving his fellow sufferers hope.
The greatest strength of the movie is how it makes use of the setting. Life
in the ghetto is but a step away from that on a concentration camp, and a
small drama can become a great one in such situation. This is also why
Manuela's character Lina, an orphan who Jacob takes care of, is gripping.
She's too young to understand much of the true grimness of the situation,
and has a consistently positive and happy outlook on everything. When Jacob
tells her he's soon being transported into some unknown destination, she
gets excited and happy, thinking of some fun travel and a change of
scenery.
That Manuela wears a smile even in situations where no real person would is
distractingly strange. I'm sure she could have done better if the director
had put real effort into her role. On the other hand, her happy scenes,
which most of her medium-large role consists of, work very well. She's very
pretty and certain to get your sympathies. She delivers her lines perfectly
credibly, and it's easy to buy that the character naturally wears a hint of
smile at all times.
This is a mini-review. We mostly write full reviews only for the best or most inspiring movies. You're welcome to submit better or new reviews. |
Jakob, der Lügner |
|||||||||||||||||||||
